This page was printed from

A young engineer, molasses, and failed sand drains

News | June 1, 2010 | By:

Editor’s Note: The October 2009 issue included lots of geosynthetics history, including this article by Bob Koerner.

Comment: “A young engineer, molasses, and failed sand drains”

From: Peter Davies, Kaytech South Africa
Posted: Nov. 1, 2009

Hi Bob and thank you for a thought-provoking lesson. I am forwarding it to a number of acquaintances in the geotechnical field in South Africa.

In my younger days (I’m 63 now!), I worked for around 10 years at Frankipile, and I spent many an hour down pile shafts being taught the dangers of smear by that doyen of geotechnics in SA, the late Prof. Jere Jennings who studied at MIT under Karl Terzaghi.

With that background, and the fact the company I now work for manufactures band drains among other geosynthetics, I think that your belief that smear may have caused the failure of the sand piles at Wilmington is well-founded. It seems incredible that a thin layer of smear could cause such a resistance to flow, but it’s quite possible.

Thanks again. This sort of practical experience is invaluable and it is good that Geosynthetics is bringing it to a wider global audience.

Best Regards.

Join the discussion

To post your thoughts on these comments, fill out the comment form on the bottom of the article “A young engineer, molasses, and failed sand drains.”

Comments and letters can contain opinions of individuals who are writing and do not necessarily reflect the views of Geosynthetics magazine or the Industrial Fabrics Association International.

Share this Story

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments are moderated and will show up after being approved.